An Immodest Proposal for the Music Industry

How music listeners can fill the industry’s “value gap”.

From the 1940s to the 1960s, countless millions of people would put a dime
in a jukebox to have a single piece of music played for them, one time. If
they wanted to hear it again, or to play another song, they’d put in
another dime.

In today’s music business, companies such as Spotify, Apple and Pandora pay
fractions of a penny to stream songs to listeners. While this is a big
business that continues to become bigger, it fails to cover what the music
industry calls a “value gap”.

They have an idea for filling that gap. So do I. The difference is that
mine can make them more money, with a strong hint from the old jukebox

For background, let’s start with this graph from the IFPI’s Global Music
Report 2018

Figure 1. Global Music Report 2018

You can see why IFPI no longer gives its full name:
International Federation of the Phonographic Industry. That phonographic
stuff is what they now call “physical”. And you see where that’s going (or
mostly gone). You also can see that what once threatened the
industry—”digital”—now accounts for most of its rebound (Figure

Figure 2. Global Recorded Music Revenues by Segment (2016)

The graphic shown in Figure 2 is also a call-out from the first. Beside it is this
text: “Before seeing a return to growth in 2015, the global recording
industry lost nearly 40% in revenues from 1999 to 2014.”

Later, the report says:

However, significant challenges need to be
overcome if the industry is going to move to sustainable growth. The whole
music sector has united in its effort to fix the fundamental flaw in
today’s music market, known as the “value gap”, where fair
revenues are not being returned to those who are creating and investing in

They want to solve this by lobbying: “The value gap is now the
industry’s single highest legislative priority as it seeks to create a
level playing field for the digital market and secure the future of the
industry.” This has worked before. Revenues from streaming and performance
rights owe a lot to royalty and copyright rates and regulations guided by
the industry. (In the early 2000s, I covered this like a rug in Linux
. See here.)

Powered by WPeMatico

The featured image was randomly selected. It is an unlikely coincidence if it is related to the post.